Take Up To 20% Off Select Cuts
SHOP THE CUT - Up To 20% OFF

Holidays are all about tradition, but what happens when you’re tired of a tradition? The problem is that the traditional turkey for Thanksgiving (and then Christmas shortly after) year after year can get pretty boring. If you’re like us, you take a small symbolic slice of turkey or ham and then fill your plate with yummy side items.  Why not try something new this Thanksgiving instead, with our turkey-dinner alternatives?

This year has been anything but traditional, so it’s the perfect time to switch things up for your holiday table. We’ve come up with some easy and delicious ideas that will please your taste buds and go well with the traditional side dishes you never tire of. Here’s to new, fun and yummy holiday traditions!

 

USDA Choice Full Beef Tenderloin

If you’re in the business of creating a statement-making table spread, there’s no better way to accomplish that dream than with our USDA Choice Full Beef Tenderloin. This selection is perfect for roasting whole or preparing into several different cuts. And, as the name implies, this is the most tender (and often most coveted) cut of beef. Our beef tenderloin will range from 3.75 pounds to 4.25 pounds and our go-to serving size rule of thumb is four servings per pound of tenderloin. And, similar to all thanksgiving mains and sides, beef tenderloin is argued to be even better the next day on a sandwich or incorporated into a stew. So that you’re prepared for the post-game to-do’s, check out our tips and tricks on the best way to reheat your beef here.

SHOP BEEF TENDERLOIN


King Crab Legs

Thinking about forgoing a meat-forward main course all together? Our Alaskan King Crab Legs are the perfect alternative and are sure to create buzz around the buffet. When determining your serving size, we recommend 1-2 pounds of king crab per adult. However, those who come with an extra Thanksgiving appetite might want to go 2-3 pounds. And if you’re worried about preparation - don’t fret. All of our king crab comes pre-cooked and flash frozen to preserve the rich flavor, so we’ve done the hard part for you. Simply thaw in the refrigerator the night before and warm using your preferred method for four minutes to heat through. When you're ready to serve, don't forget your favorite dipping sauce! We recommend Mr. Stick’s Original Just Add Butter Seafood Seasoning - it’s easy to prepare and is finger-lickin’ good.

SHOP KING CRAB


Ribeye Steaks

If your Thanksgiving gathering was on the slim-side last year you’re probably hunting for a way to make this year’s meal extra special. Turkey and ham are always great and well received, but why not treat your guests with something new and individualized? Our USDA Prime Ribeye Steaks are offered in 12 and 16 ounce cuts and are one of our most lean and flavorful meat offerings. The best part? Ribeyes will pair well with any of your traditional go-to Thanksgiving side options, and in our opinion, sweet potato casserole makes for the perfect balance of hearty and sweet. 

SHOP MEATS


We’re convinced these Thanksgiving dinner alternatives are the best and most delicious way to freshen up your table this year. Don’t forget to always start with premium quality ingredients for the best results. And - if someone compliments your main-course switch-up - take note of our subscription offerings as a holiday gift idea. We wish you and yours a happy and appetizing Thanksgiving!

Want the latest on recipes, deals and new releases? Sign up here!

What’s important to you is important to us.

Market House
Quick Ship
Free overnight shipping on all orders. Dinner when you say so!
Free overnight shipping applies on orders $150+ and next-day delivery applies to orders placed Monday-Thursday before 3pm ET. Orders placed after 3pm ET on Thursday will ship on Monday.
Market House
Flash Frozen
Everything is flash frozen for quality and ships with dry ice to stay that way.
Market House
Eco-Friendly
Packaging that's non-toxic and as eco-friendly as we could find.

Shop By Collection

USDA Prime Beef

Angus-Bred

Poultry

Free-Range & Antibiotic Free

Pork

Heritage-Bred & Antibiotic Free

Lamb

Grass-Fed & Certified Humane

Seafood

King Crab, Fish, Shrimp and more!

Something went wrong, please contact us!

Cart

Use code DOGGY20 to get 20% off
orders of $90 or more!
Subtotal: